Skip to content
StringandStock

Bolts & Broadheads

Crossbow bolt weight, explained

Around 400 grains complete is the mainstream answer for deer. The number that matters more is the minimum in your bow's manual, and why it exists.

By Mike M.Updated

String & Stock earns a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices come from Amazon and change; the date beside every price is when we last verified it. Full disclosure.

Wicked Ridge Match 400 from Wicked Ridge
Top pick
Wicked Ridge Match 400 from Wicked Ridge

Wicked Ridge Match 400

Wicked Ridge
9.4/ 10Six matched 400-grain bolts at a sane price

Six 20-inch shafts at 400 grains with a 46-grain aluminum insert that produces 14 percent front-of-center, which Wicked Ridge claims gives up to 20 percent tighter groups than its previous arrow.

Read the full assessment

Ranked

Quick picks

#ProductWeightScorePrice
Rank 1
Wicked Ridge Match 400 from Wicked Ridge

Wicked Ridge Match 400

Six matched 400-grain bolts at a sane price

400 gr9.4$69.99Match 400
Rank 2
Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts from Carbon Express

Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts

The tightest published straightness tolerance here

390 gr9.7$29.97Maxima Contour Crossbolts
Rank 3
TenPoint EVO-X Lighted CenterPunch16 from TenPoint

TenPoint EVO-X Lighted CenterPunch16

Short, heavy and lit, for a reverse-draw bow

400 gr9.6$119.99EVO-X Lighted CenterPunch16
Rank 4
Killer Instinct KillerTech Lighted 20-inch from Killer Instinct

Killer Instinct KillerTech Lighted 20-inch

Lighted bolts for a Killer Instinct

430 gr with 100 gr point9.1$49.99KillerTech Lighted 20-inch
Rank 5
Guide Gear Trophy Hunter Pro (by Victory) from Victory Archery

Guide Gear Trophy Hunter Pro (by Victory)

Lighted nocks with a heavy brass insert

Not published9.1$49.99Guide Gear Trophy Hunter Pro (by Victory)

#ad Prices come from Amazon and change. How this site is funded. Scores are our published rubric — how we evaluate.

The short answer

Around 400 grains complete, including the point, is the mainstream crossbow arrow weight for deer and close to what most bows ship with. The hard limit is your bow's published minimum total arrow weight: below it, energy the arrow should absorb goes into the limbs instead.

Arrow weight is where a crossbow setup gets quietly decided. It sets your velocity, which sets your scope's speed dial, which sets whether your 40-yard hold is right. And it has one hard floor that is a safety specification rather than a preference.

The minimum weight, which is not negotiable

Every crossbow publishes a minimum total arrow weight in its manual. The reason is mechanical: the limbs store a fixed amount of energy and the arrow carries it away. A lighter arrow carries away less, and what is left stays in the bow as vibration and shock through the limbs, cams and rail.

It is the same mechanism as a dry fire, in miniature, on every shot. It shortens string life, loosens hardware and in the worst case damages the limbs. There is no performance argument that outweighs it.

In detail

Bolts across the weight range

01Six matched 400-grain bolts at a sane price

Wicked Ridge Match 400

Wicked Ridge
9.4/ 10

Six 20-inch shafts at 400 grains with a 46-grain aluminum insert that produces 14 percent front-of-center, which Wicked Ridge claims gives up to 20 percent tighter groups than its previous arrow. Six per pack is the practical detail: that is a full quiver and spares in one purchase.

Published specValue
Length20 in
Weight400 gr
Straightnesswithin .004 in
Insert46 gr aluminum
Front of center14%
NockAlpha-Nock HP with aluminum bushing
Vanes3.5 in Bohning X Vanes, slight offset

Why we recommend it

  • Six per pack, which is a quiver's worth in one box
  • 14 percent front-of-center published, which most makers do not state
  • A 46-grain aluminum insert rather than a plastic one
  • Alpha-Nock engages the string deeply, which reduces shoot-over

Good to know

.004 inch straightness is looser than the Carbon Express and TenPoint shafts

Our rubric

Flight
9.3
Penetration
9.4
Consistency
9.0
Durability
9.4
Value
9.7
02The tightest published straightness tolerance here
Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts from Carbon Express
See today’s price on the Maxima Contour Crossbolts$29.97

$39.99 25% off

#ad How we are funded · Price as of November 20, 2026

Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts

Carbon Express
9.7/ 10

Dual Spine Weight Forward is not marketing: the shaft has two spines, a stiffer section forward of a softer one, and Carbon Express claims it cuts oscillation in half. The figures are the reason to buy — .002 inch straightness checked to a ten-thousandth, spine sorted to .0025 inch, weight sorted to 1 grain. Nothing else on this page publishes that level of sorting.

Published specValue
Length20 in
Weight390 gr
Diameter0.348 in
Straightness+/- .002 in
Spine tolerance+/- .0025 in
Weight tolerance+/- 1.0 gr
Vanes and nocks3 in Dragon Vanes; moon nocks installed, C-Nocks included

Why we recommend it

  • Straightness, spine and weight tolerances all published and all tight
  • Dual-spine construction claims 50 percent less oscillation
  • Both moon nocks and flat C-Nocks in the pack, so it fits more bows
  • Laser-matched sets rather than randomly boxed shafts

Good to know

Three per pack, so a full quiver costs more than it looks

Our rubric

Flight
9.8
Penetration
9.2
Consistency
9.8
Durability
9.4
Value
9.0
03Short, heavy and lit, for a reverse-draw bow

TenPoint EVO-X Lighted CenterPunch16

TenPoint
9.6/ 10

400 grains in a 16-inch shaft, inspected to .001 inch straightness, with a one-piece lighted nock that the bowstring activates on firing. Short bolts exist because reverse-draw and compact bows need them. The brass insert pushes weight forward, which is what gets a short arrow to behave.

Published specValue
Length16 in
Weight400 gr
Straightnesswithin .001 in
Weight matchingwithin 1 gr per arrow
Carbon33 MSI modulus, LAZER-TECH weave
NockAlpha-Nock HP with Alpha-Blaze lighted unit, ~24 h battery
Vanes2.1 in Q2i, slight offset

Why we recommend it

  • .001 inch straightness is the tightest claim on this page
  • The lighted nock activates on the shot and pulls out to switch off
  • A brass insert forward keeps a short shaft stable
  • 400 grains carries energy well for the length

Good to know

16 inches fits reverse-draw and compact bows, not every bow

Our rubric

Flight
9.8
Penetration
9.5
Consistency
9.8
Durability
9.5
Value
8.4
04Lighted bolts for a Killer Instinct

Killer Instinct KillerTech Lighted 20-inch

Killer Instinct
9.1/ 10

430 grains complete with a 100-grain point, a .300 inside diameter and a lighted half-moon nock fitted at the factory, on a carbon composite shaft Killer Instinct spines for its faster bows. Straightness is published at .005 inch, which is the loosest figure on this site — this is the lighted-nock answer for a Killer Instinct, not the tolerance answer.

Published specValue
Length20 in
Weight430 gr with 100 gr point
Straightness0.005 in
Inside diameter0.300 in
Outside diameter0.346 in
NockHalf-moon, lighted, fitted at the factory
Vanes3 in
FitsNot published

Why we recommend it

  • Lighted nocks fitted at the factory rather than retrofitted
  • 430 grains complete is heavy enough for the largest quarry on this site
  • A .300 inch inside diameter is the standard crossbow size, so points and inserts are easy to source
  • Killer Instinct publishes weight, straightness and both diameters

Good to know

.005 inch straightness is the loosest tolerance published here

Our rubric

Flight
9.0
Penetration
9.4
Consistency
8.7
Durability
9.2
Value
9.2
05Lighted nocks with a heavy brass insert

Guide Gear Trophy Hunter Pro (by Victory)

Victory Archery
9.1/ 10

Made by Victory Archery, carrying a 110-grain brass insert — the heaviest on this page — plus a red lighted half-moon nock and Victory's ICE coating, which the listing credits with easier penetration and less noise through the rail. The heavy insert is the reason to pick these: front-of-center weight is what makes a bolt fly like a dart.

Published specValue
Length20 in
Brass insert110 gr
NockRed lighted half-moon
Carbon100% standard high modulus
Vanes3 in Bohning X-Vanes
CoatingVictory ICE
StraightnessNot published

Why we recommend it

  • A 110-grain brass insert is the heaviest here, which maximizes front-of-center
  • Lighted nocks included rather than a separate purchase
  • ICE coating reduces rail friction and noise

Good to know

No straightness tolerance published

Our rubric

Flight
9.0
Penetration
9.5
Consistency
8.7
Durability
9.2
Value
9.3

The weights on this site

BoltLengthShaft weightInsertNotes
Excalibur Diablo18 in250 grHeavier front insertBuilt for Excalibur recurves
Killer Instinct KillerTech Lighted20 in430 gr with 100 gr pointNot published.300 in ID, lighted
Carbon Express Maxima Contour20 in390 grNot publishedDual Spine Weight Forward
Wicked Ridge Match 40020 in400 gr46 gr aluminum, 14% FOCSix per pack
TenPoint EVO-X CenterPunch1616 in400 grBrassFor reverse-draw and compact bows
Guide Gear Trophy Hunter Pro20 inNot published110 gr brassHeaviest insert here
Note that "weight" means different things across listings: some quote the complete arrow, some the shaft. Check which.

What weight trades against

  • Heavier is slower. Velocity drops, and the drop past 40 yards steepens.
  • Heavier carries more energy. Kinetic energy scales with mass, so penetration improves.
  • Heavier is quieter. More of the bow's energy leaves with the arrow instead of dissipating as vibration. See crossbow noise.
  • Heavier is more forgiving in wind. More mass, more momentum, less deflection.
  • Lighter is flatter. Which forgives a misjudged range, up to your bow's minimum weight.

Front-of-center, which matters more than total weight

Where the weight sits is more consequential than how much there is. Front-of-center is the proportion of the arrow's mass forward of its balance point, and more of it makes the arrow fly nose-first and recover from imperfections faster.

Wicked Ridge publishes 14 percent FOC on the Match 400 from a 46 gr aluminum insert, and claims up to 20 percent tighter groups than its previous arrow. Guide Gear's Victory-made bolts carry a 110 gr brass insert. TenPoint uses a brass insert on the CenterPunch16 to get a short 16 in shaft to behave.

Raising FOC with a heavier insert rather than a heavier head is often the better route: you get the stability without changing your broadhead weight and re-verifying everything.

How the complete arrow adds up

  1. Shaft, which is what a grains-per-inch figure describes. Barnett's Headhunter publishes 13.78 gr/in, so a 20 in shaft is about 276 gr.
  2. Insert, 46-110 gr on this site.
  3. Point or broadhead, 100 gr or 125 gr.
  4. Nock and vanes, a small but real contribution — a lighted nock adds weight behind the balance point, which lowers FOC.

A 20 in shaft at 13.78 gr/in with a 100 gr point lands near the 375 gr mark; add a 95 gr brass insert instead of a light one and you are over 400 gr.

Settle on one arrow

The strongest practical advice on this page: pick one bolt, verify your zero with it, and buy it by the dozen. Mixing 390 gr and 400 gr bolts gives you two trajectories out of one bow, and your scope's speed dial can only be set for one of them.

Weight is one of four figures that have to be right. What size crossbow bolts do I need covers the other three, and crossbow bolts by brand names the shaft that fits your bow.

For one animal where this arithmetic decides the purchase, see best crossbow bolts for elk - which also explains why the insert, not the shaft, is where most of an elk arrow's extra mass comes from.

Frequently asked questions

How heavy should a crossbow bolt be for deer?
Around 400 grains complete, including the point, which is close to what most bows ship with. The hard limit is your bow's published minimum total arrow weight — going heavier is almost always safe, going lighter is not.
What happens if a crossbow bolt is too light?
Energy the arrow should carry away stays in the bow as vibration and shock through the limbs, cams and rail. It is the dry-fire mechanism in miniature on every shot: shorter string life, loosening hardware, and in the worst case damaged limbs.
Do heavier crossbow bolts hit harder?
They carry more kinetic energy and penetrate better, yes, because energy scales with mass. They also leave slower and drop more steeply past 40 yards. They are quieter too, because more of the bow's energy leaves with the arrow.
What is a good front-of-center for a crossbow bolt?
Wicked Ridge publishes 14 percent on its Match 400 and claims up to 20 percent tighter groups from it. Raising FOC with a heavier brass insert — 95 to 110 grains on this site — is often better than a heavier broadhead, because it does not change your broadhead weight.
Can I mix different crossbow bolt weights?
You should not. Your scope's speed dial is calibrated for a velocity that depends on arrow weight, so two weights means two trajectories from one bow. Settle on one bolt, verify your zero with it, and buy it by the dozen.

Our recommendation

Top pick

Wicked Ridge Match 400

9.4/ 10

Six matched 400-grain bolts at a sane price.

Runner-up

Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts

9.7/ 10

The tightest published straightness tolerance here.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts from Carbon Express

Bolts & Broadheads

The best crossbow bolts

Five bolt sets ranked on published straightness and weight sorting, with the four compatibility checks that come first.

G5 Montec M3 100 gr from G5 Outdoors

Bolts & Broadheads

100 vs 125 grain broadheads

What 25 grains actually changes: front-of-center, velocity and your zero. Plus which heads come in which weight.

Carbon Express Maxima Contour Crossbolts from Carbon Express

Bolts & Broadheads

Crossbow bolt vs arrow

Why bolt and arrow now mean the same thing, and the four specifications that actually decide compatibility.

Crossbows sorted by what you can actually cock, carry and shoot quietly.