Skip to content
StringandStock

Best for deer

The best crossbow broadheads for deer

A whitetail is a large, thin-skinned animal, so you have energy to spend on a wide cut — until the shot quarters into a shoulder. Five heads, with the cases they suit.

By Mike M.Updated

String & Stock earns a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices come from Amazon and change; the date beside every price is when we last verified it. Full disclosure.

Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC from Rage
Top pickBest for deer
Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC from Rage

Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC

Rage
9.4/ 10The mechanical most crossbow hunters land on

A one-piece titanium ferrule, .

Read the full assessment

Ranked

Quick picks

#ProductCutting diameterScorePrice
Rank 1
Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC from Rage

Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC

The mechanical most crossbow hunters land on

Not published9.4$54.99Hypodermic Trypan NC
Rank 2
G5 Montec M3 100 gr from G5 Outdoors

G5 Montec M3 100 gr

One-piece steel, nothing to come loose

1-1/16 in9.6$54.95G5 Montec M3 100 gr
Rank 3
Slick Trick GrizzTrick Pro Series from Slick Trick

Slick Trick GrizzTrick Pro Series

The most total cut from a fixed head

Not published9.5$49.50GrizzTrick Pro Series
Rank 4
Muzzy Trocar HBX Hybrid from Muzzy

Muzzy Trocar HBX Hybrid

Fixed and mechanical blades on one head

Not published9.2$40.75Trocar HBX Hybrid
Rank 5
NAP Spitfire Crossbow from New Archery Products

NAP Spitfire Crossbow

The cheapest proven mechanical

1.5 in9.2$29.97NAP Spitfire Crossbow

#ad Prices come from Amazon and change. How this site is funded. Scores are our published rubric — how we evaluate.

The short answer

For whitetail deer with a crossbow, a 1.5-inch mechanical and a 1-1/8-inch one-piece fixed head are both excellent and they suit different shots. The mechanical gives a wider wound channel on a broadside shot; the fixed head penetrates better when the shot quarters into a shoulder.

Crossbows generate considerably more kinetic energy than most compound bows — published figures on this site run to 155.5 ft-lb — and commonly cited guidance puts whitetail deer around 25 ft-lb. You have energy to spend. The question is what you spend it on.

In detail

Five heads for deer

01The mechanical most crossbow hunters land on

Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC

Rage
9.4/ 10

A one-piece titanium ferrule, .039-inch stainless blades, a hybrid tip and No Collar retention — meaning the blades are held closed by the ferrule geometry rather than a rubber band you have to replace every shot. For a fast bow, the collar is the part that fails, so removing it matters.

Published specValue
Weight100 gr
Blade thickness0.039 in
TypeMechanical, expandable
FerruleOne-piece titanium
RetentionNo Collar
TipHybrid
Per pack3

Why we recommend it

  • No Collar retention removes the consumable rubber band
  • A titanium ferrule is lighter and stronger than aluminum
  • .039-inch blades are thick for a mechanical
  • Ferrule alignment adapter helps it spin true

Good to know

Most expensive broadhead here

Our rubric

Flight
9.4
Penetration
9.3
Consistency
9.5
Durability
9.5
Value
8.5
02One-piece steel, nothing to come loose

G5 Montec M3 100 gr

G5 Outdoors
9.6/ 10

One solid piece of 420 stainless steel with a 1-1/16 inch cut, no vents, cut-on-contact geometry and every head spin-tested before it ships. There are no blades to replace, no screws to loosen and no collar to fail. For a fast bow, a fixed one-piece head is the most reliable thing you can put on the front of a bolt.

Published specValue
Weight100 gr (125 also offered)
Cutting diameter1-1/16 in
Blades3, fixed
ConstructionOne-piece MIM, 420 stainless steel, no vents
SharpeningDiamond cut, cut-on-contact
Quality control100% spin-tested
Per pack3

Why we recommend it

  • One piece: no blades, screws or collars to fail
  • Every head spin-tested before it ships
  • Resharpenable, so a head survives more than one animal
  • Cut-on-contact geometry starts cutting immediately

Good to know

A 1-1/16 inch cut is narrow next to a 2.25-inch mechanical

Our rubric

Flight
9.2
Penetration
9.8
Consistency
9.7
Durability
9.8
Value
9.3
03The most total cut from a fixed head

Slick Trick GrizzTrick Pro Series

Slick Trick
9.5/ 10

Four .035-inch stainless Lutz blades in a short Super Steel ferrule giving 2-1/2 inches of total cut, held by the Alcatraz blade lock. Short, fat and fixed: it flies like a field point because there is barely any ferrule forward of the blades to plane in the wind.

Published specValue
Weight100 gr
Total cut2-1/2 in (1-1/4 in + 1-1/4 in)
Blade thickness0.035 in
BladesStainless Lutz, 4
FerruleSuper Steel
Blade lockAlcatraz
TipNot published

Why we recommend it

  • 2-1/2 inches of total cut is the widest fixed-head figure here
  • A short ferrule means less wind planing
  • Alcatraz blade lock keeps blades seated through bone
  • Blades are replaceable rather than the whole head

Good to know

Four fixed blades need a well-tuned bow to fly cleanly

Our rubric

Flight
9.3
Penetration
9.7
Consistency
9.5
Durability
9.7
Value
9.2
04Fixed and mechanical blades on one head

Muzzy Trocar HBX Hybrid

Muzzy
9.2/ 10

Four blades: two fixed, two mechanical, with the fixed pair offset to induce spin. It is a genuine middle path — the fixed blades cut on contact and the mechanicals widen the channel, and the chisel tip and stainless ferrule are built to survive bone.

Published specValue
Weight100 gr
Blades4 (2 fixed, 2 mechanical)
TypeHybrid
TipChisel
FerruleStainless steel
Design noteOffset fixed blades induce spin
Cutting diameterNot published

Why we recommend it

  • Fixed blades cut on contact even if the mechanicals do not open
  • Offset fixed blades stabilize the arrow in flight
  • A stainless ferrule and chisel tip for bone

Good to know

No cutting diameter published

Our rubric

Flight
9.0
Penetration
9.4
Consistency
9.2
Durability
9.5
Value
9.2
05The cheapest proven mechanical

NAP Spitfire Crossbow

New Archery Products
9.2/ 10

A 1.5-inch cutting diameter with Diamize-sharpened blades and a Trophy tip, for under thirty dollars. The Spitfire has been in production long enough that its failure modes are known, and the crossbow-specific version exists because the standard one was not holding up at crossbow speeds.

Published specValue
Weight100 gr
Cutting diameter1.5 in
TypeMechanical
BladesDiamize sharpened
TipTrophy tip
Blade thicknessNot published
Per pack3

Why we recommend it

  • A 1.5-inch cut at the lowest price of any mechanical here
  • The crossbow-specific version is built for the velocity
  • A long production record

Good to know

No blade thickness or speed rating published

Our rubric

Flight
9.2
Penetration
8.9
Consistency
9.0
Durability
8.8
Value
9.8

How we picked

Cut diameter, penetration characteristics and reliability, weighted for the shots a crossbow hunter actually takes — close, often from a blind or stand, sometimes at a quartering angle. See our methodology.

Which head for which shot

HeadCutTypeBest shot
Rage Hypodermic Trypan NCNot publishedMechanical, No CollarBroadside, inside 40 yd
G5 Montec M31-1/16 inFixed, one pieceAny angle, including a quartering shoulder
Slick Trick GrizzTrick2-1/2 in totalFixed, 4 bladeBroadside, with a well-tuned bow
Muzzy Trocar HBXNot publishedHybrid, 4 bladeAny angle — fixed blades always cut
NAP Spitfire Crossbow1.5 inMechanicalBroadside, on a budget
Published cut figures where makers state them.

The broadside case: mechanical

On a square broadside shot behind the shoulder, there is no heavy bone in the way and the limiting factor is the size of the hole. That is where a mechanical earns its keep: a 1.5 in cut through both lungs produces a blood trail a fixed 1-1/8 in head does not.

For a crossbow specifically, pick one that cannot deploy early: the Rage Trypan NC's No Collar design, or a head with a published speed rating. See broadheads for 400 fps bows.

The quartering case: fixed

A quartering-to shot means the arrow may meet the shoulder, and a mechanical that has already spent energy opening is the wrong tool. A one-piece steel fixed head with cut-on-contact geometry drives through: the G5 Montec M3's 1-1/16 in cut and all-steel construction, or TenPoint's version of the same design.

The hybrid Muzzy Trocar HBX covers both cases: two fixed blades cut on contact regardless, two mechanicals widen the channel when there is energy to do so.

Grain weight for deer

One hundred grains is the default and what your bow's included arrows are matched to. 125 grains pushes more weight forward, improving front-of-center and penetration, at the cost of some velocity — and it changes your zero. If you switch, re-verify at 40 yards. See 100 vs 125 grain.

The pre-season routine

  1. Spin test every head on the shaft. Tip wobble means re-seat or replace.
  2. Shoot three into a broadhead-capable target at 20 yards. Confirm they group with your field points.
  3. Never into a bag target. Broadheads shred the fill. See broadhead targets.
  4. Check your state's rules on minimum cutting diameter, which some states specify for big game.
  5. Replace blades after any hit. A used edge is not a hunting edge.

What we would carry

A quiver with the mechanical you have zeroed, and the knowledge of which shots to pass on. If you hunt thick cover where quartering shots are the norm rather than the exception, carry the one-piece fixed head instead and accept the narrower cut — penetration you have beats a wound channel you did not reach.

The head is half the arrow. Best crossbow bolts for deer ranks the shafts to screw it into, on pack size, published straightness and weight sorting rather than on penetration you do not need on this animal.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best broadhead for deer with a crossbow?
For a broadside shot, a crossbow-rated mechanical around 1.5 inches — the Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC is the pick here. For shots that may quarter into a shoulder, a one-piece fixed head like the G5 Montec M3. The Muzzy Trocar HBX hybrid covers both cases.
How much kinetic energy do you need for deer?
Commonly cited guidance puts whitetail deer around 25 foot-pounds, and the published crossbow figures on this site run from 134 to 152. Energy is not your limiting factor on a crossbow — shot placement and broadhead performance are. See crossbow kinetic energy.
Should I use a 100 or 125 grain broadhead for deer?
One hundred grains is the default and matches most bows' included arrows. 125 grains improves front-of-center and penetration at the cost of some speed, and it changes your zero — so re-verify at 40 yards if you switch.
Do broadheads need to match my field points?
They need to group with them. Shoot three broadheads into a broadhead-capable target and compare to your field-point group. Matching the grain weight helps, and if a fixed head still will not group, check spin, nock indexing and cocking evenness before blaming the head.
How many broadheads do I need for a season?
A quiver's worth plus spares — most come three to a pack. Replace blades after any hit, because a used edge is not a hunting edge, and keep a few field points of the same grain weight for practice so you are not shooting hunting heads at targets.

Our recommendation

Top pick

Rage Hypodermic Trypan NC

9.4/ 10

The mechanical most crossbow hunters land on.

Runner-up

G5 Montec M3 100 gr

9.6/ 10

One-piece steel, nothing to come loose.

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.

Sources

TenPoint Pro Elite 400 from TenPoint

Bolts & Broadheads

The best crossbow bolts for deer

Five crossbow bolts for deer, ranked on how many come in the pack, what straightness and weight sorting the maker publishes, and whether the nock matches your string.

G5 Montec M3 100 gr from G5 Outdoors

Bolts & Broadheads

100 vs 125 grain broadheads

What 25 grains actually changes: front-of-center, velocity and your zero. Plus which heads come in which weight.

Crossbows sorted by what you can actually cock, carry and shoot quietly.